Thank you so much for your generous donation to the "Get me the hell out of Dodge" fund. It was good to see Teresa and actually spend some quality time with her. All things considered, Teresa's doing well. She was pretty upset, though, about your refusal to attend her wedding and recognize her marriage to Bob. To be honest, I agree with her sentiment, and I have a hard time following your rationale.
You're aware that neither of them is Catholic, right? So, why are you so insistent that Bob follow an authority that neither he nor Teresa recognize? And before you start on what the Vatican says, let me ask you this: Do you consider George and Kenya married? What about Aunt Janet and John?
I can understand that you would prefer Teresa and Bob to do everything by the book, but it's really not up to you. She's a grown woman in her thirties. She can make her own decisions. Furthermore, Bob doesn't want an annulment. Aside from the fact that he's not Catholic, he finds it dishonest to deny that his previous marriage was valid, and for you to insist that he does, without actually knowing him, is insulting and offensive.
So why the refusal? Do you think you'll score some extra salvation points or something? Do you expect to show up at the Pearly Gates, and St. Peter will say, "Well, it looks like everything checks out. Wait, what's this? You recognized your daughter's marriage to a divorcee? To the pits with you!" Are you just too broke to go to Seattle? If that's the case, man up and admit it.
Or is it because it somehow makes Bob a polygamist? That's just silly. As far as the Church cares, he's only married to his ex. As far as the law cares, he's only going to be married to Teresa. Either way you look at it, it's not polygamy. Furthermore, nobody who matters in the relationship (i.e. Teresa, Bob, and Isaac) is Catholic. Why should either of them follow a set of rules that neither of them accept?
George and Kenya aren't Catholic. Is their marriage invalid, too? How do you think that makes them feel?
Have you thought about the long-term consequences? I mean, refusing to attend your own daughter's wedding because of a technicality that doesn't even apply to them is something that will taint your relationship with her forever.
Let me tell you the neatest thing about spending a week in Seattle.
I got to see Teresa in her element. She wasn't visiting from out of town. She wasn't passing through. She was at home with someone she loves. She and Bob really complement each other, and just watching them interact in a genuinely human way just cemented their relationship for me. They don't need a piece of paper to validate that.
Furthermore, Teresa is fantastic with Isaac. She has really embraced her role as his future stepmother.
But recognizing that in her is somehow a sin. Or perhaps an occasion of sin.
So, here’re your consequences for not going to your daughter's wedding (due to your strict adherence to an unrecognized authority):
1. You don't get to share in what's supposed to be the happiest day of her life.
2. You don't get to take on the grandparent role with Isaac.
3. There will always be a rift between you and Teresa.
4. You will, by extension, alienate George and Kenya, as well as me and Tina.
5. You'll serve as an object lesson as to how zealous devotion to a religion can divide families.
6. You'll miss out on the reception and cake. (Incidentally, saying you can't go to the wedding, but you'll be happy to attend the reception? That's just low.)
Ultimately, what it boils down to is this: You're breaking your only daughter's heart out of some misguided sense of self-righteous indignation, and there's no saying how well that wound will heal.
- Never Lost a Game